Mar 11 2008
Teens’ Knowledge of History, Literature Is Very Poor
Teens’ Knowledge of History, Literature Is Very Poor – 3/3/2008 2:05:00 PM - School Library Journal
This posting made me go and download the 24-page report Still at Risk: What Students Don’t Know, Even Now to read.
One of the comments that struck me was “almost 20% of 1200 respondents to a national telephone survey do not know who our enemy was in World War II”—primarily because of a particularly embarassing situation that happened to me when I was a senior in high school. (Humiliation alert!)
We spent the week between Christmas and New Year’s Day in the Florida Keys. I wanted to work on my tan and stayed at the pool while the rest of my family had a late afternoon nap. I was the only person left poolside. Not long after, a man showed up and was chit-chatting with me. He struck up the conversation by asking if I was on my honeymoon. (I told him no, I was still in high school and implied I was jailbait.)
He went on to complain about our education system—legitimately, as you’ll soon see! He said something along the lines of, “Who won World War II?” and having never taken a history class that went beyond reconstruction but not wanting to look like the cultural illiterate I was, I responded, “Did anyone really win?” (Answer a question with a question, classic avoidance!) Instead of realizing I was a dumb blonde, he jumped all over that, “Exactly!” (I honestly don’t remember much else about that conversation other than thinking he was an easy con.)
The other thing education-related thing I remember from that trip was that I was to memorize Hamlet’s “To be, or not to be” soliloquy for my English class. I’d forgotten my book and needed to go buy one while we were on our vacation. We picked up a copy of Hamlet and a Key Lime pie in the same shopping trip.
When I went to college, as electives I took both a 20th century US and 20th century world history class. At the end of the world history course, I went up to the professor and thanked him and told him that I’d never had a class that went past reconstruction and I appreciated his class. He laughed at me. Even so, those were two of my favorite general education courses and probably influenced my choice to minor in history in college. I had to be sure I wasn’t caught like that again. I also bought E. D. Hirsch’s Dictionary of Cultural Literacy to help ensure that I became a more aware adult than I was teenager.
I hope fewer students graduate from my old high school not knowing the answer to that stranger’s question than did twenty years ago! At the very least, I hope I’ve given them the skills to find the answer if they don’t know it!
LM_NET
